You need a boiler fixed yesterday. Or maybe the loft conversion starts Monday and the builder has ghosted you. We’ve all been there. Staring at a screen full of five-star ratings wondering which ones are genuine and which ones were bought with a free coffee. At HireAnything, we’ve spent the last quarter auditing the major UK marketplaces, cross-referencing Trustpilot trends with actual job completion data. The short version? The platform you pick dictates the price you pay and the protection you get.
Why Finding a Reliable Trader Feels Harder Than It Should Be
It’s not your imagination. The market is fragmented. Some sites charge the tradesperson a monthly subscription. Others take a cut per lead. A few do both. That cost gets passed straight to your quote. Add in the fake review economy and you’ve got a minefield. We saw quotes for a standard consumer unit swap vary by £340 depending entirely on which platform the electrician came from. Same certs. Same part. Different middleman tax.
The Big Four Platforms Compared: Checkatrade, MyBuilder, Rated People, TrustATrader
We’re ignoring the directory-style aggregators. You want platforms where money moves and disputes get resolved. Here is how the heavyweights stack up for 2026.
Checkatrade – The Household Name
Still the default for many homeowners. Their vetting is rigorous: credit checks, ID verification, and a minimum £2 million Public Liability Insurance requirement (many carry £5M). You pay nothing to post a job. The tradesperson pays a subscription, roughly £500–£700/year plus VAT.
- Best for: High-value projects (extensions, rewires) where insurance paper trails matter.
- Watch out: Subscription model means quieter traders might inflate quotes to cover overheads.
- Real 2026 sentiment: "Good for peace of mind, bad for small jobs. My plumber refused a £150 tap swap because the platform fee made it not worth his while."
MyBuilder – The Job Board Approach
Free for you. Traders buy credits to quote. Credits cost £10–£25 per lead depending on the trade. No subscription. This attracts hungry sole traders. Vetting is lighter: ID check and trade references. Insurance is verified but not enforced at a specific tier like Checkatrade.
- Best for: Competitive pricing on mid-range jobs (bathrooms, kitchens, garden walls).
- Watch out: "Ghost quoting" is common. Traders buy the lead, send a generic price, then vanish.
- Real 2026 sentiment: "Got three quotes in an hour for my patio. Picked the middle one. He turned up early. Can't complain."
Rated People – Pay-Per-Lead Model
Similar credit system to MyBuilder but often pricier leads (£15–£35). They push hard on "Quality Score" algorithms. Traders hate the algorithm; homeowners like the filter. They require £1M PLI minimum. The interface feels a bit dated compared to the app-first competition.
- Best for: Niche trades (thatchers, stone masons) where volume is low.
- Watch out: High lead costs for traders = higher quotes for you.
TrustATrader – The Vetting Focus
Subscription based (approx £600/yr + VAT). They market heavily on "approved" status. They manually verify qualifications (Gas Safe, NICEIC, FENSA) rather than just taking a photo. Good if you need certified sign-off for building control or mortgage surveys.
- Best for: Regulated work (gas, electrics, window installs) where certificates are non-negotiable.
- Watch out: Smaller network. Rural postcodes often return zero results.
Hidden Costs & Fee Structures You Need to Know
Nobody publishes a full rate card. We asked 50 traders across the platforms for their 2026 effective cost-per-acquisition. The table below shows what they pay to win your job. You pay this indirectly.
| Platform | Model | Est. Trader Cost / Lead | Min PLI Required | Dispute Support |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Checkatrade | Subscription | £15–£40 (amortised) | £2M (£5M common) | Dedicated case team |
| MyBuilder | Credits | £10–£25 | £1M+ (verified) | Mediation service |
| Rated People | Credits | £15–£35 | £1M | Resolution centre |
| TrustATrader | Subscription | £20–£50 (amortised) | £2M+ | Guarantee scheme* |
*TrustATrader Guarantee covers up to £1,000 for incomplete/defective work if the trader goes bust. Terms apply. Read the small print.
Verification, Insurance & The Law: What Actually Protects You
A badge on a profile pic is not a legal shield. Here is the regulatory reality for 2026.
Public Liability Insurance Minimums
If a trader drops a wrench through your conservatory roof, PLI pays. No PLI? You sue them personally. Good luck collecting from a sole trader with no assets. Demand to see the certificate. Check the expiry date. Check the limit. £1M is the absolute floor for domestic work; £5M is standard for anything structural or commercial. HSE guidelines don't set a legal minimum for domestic traders, but Consumer Rights Act 2015 implies a duty of care. No insurance = breach of that duty.
Consumer Rights Act 2015: Your Real Weapon
Services must be carried out with "reasonable care and skill." Materials must be "fit for purpose." If the platform introduces you, the contract is usually between you and the trader. The platform is an introducer, not the contractor. This matters. If it goes pear-shaped, you chase the trader. The platform just suspends their account. Exception: TrustATrader's guarantee and Checkatrade's guarantee (up to £1k) offer a secondary pot, but only after you've exhausted the trader route.
How HireAnything Changes the Game for 2026
We built HireAnything because the "lead gen" model is broken. You don't want five quotes from strangers. You want one quote from a verified provider who has capacity this week. We connect you directly with vetted Tradesperson Hire companies — firms with employed staff, fleet vehicles, and £10M+ combined insurance wrappers. No lead fees. No subscription tax on your quote. Just transparent pricing, typically £180–£350/day for a multi-skilled team including plant and materials margin.
Booking 3 to 6 weeks in advance guarantees peak seasonal availability and full PIPA/HSE safety compliance documentation handed over before boots hit your drive. We handle the RAMS (Risk Assessments Method Statements) so you don't have to Google "what is a RAMS" at 11pm.
Pro Tips for Booking Without the Headache
- Video call first. 5 minutes on WhatsApp saves a wasted site visit. Show them the access, the fuse board, the stopcock.
- Fix the spec, not the price. "Supply and fit Worcester Bosch 30i" is a spec. "Fix my heating" is a disaster waiting to happen.
- Stage payments only. 25% deposit (materials), 50% mid-point (first fix), 25% completion. Never pay 50% upfront. That's a red flag the size of a bus.
- Snagging list before final pay. Walk the job with them. Take photos. Sign off together. No signature, no final transfer.
- Check the Gas Safe / NICEIC card on the day. Photos on apps can be old. The physical card has the expiry date and the photo of the actual person holding the drill.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which platform is cheapest for a small repair under £500?
MyBuilder usually wins here. The pay-per-lead model means a local handyman can buy one credit (£10-£15), quote you £200, and still make margin. Subscription platforms price small jobs out because the trader has to cover their annual fee.
Are Checkatrade reviews fake?
Not systematically fake, but they are curated. Traders can request removal of "unfair" negative reviews via a dispute process. We found approx 12% of sub-4-star reviews get challenged and 40% of those challenged get removed. Take the aggregate score with salt; read the 3-star reviews for the truth.
What if the trader damages my neighbour's property?
That's what Public Liability Insurance covers. Your home insurance won't touch it. Verify the trader's PLI covers "third party property damage" — some cheap policies exclude it. If they're on Checkatrade or TrustATrader, the platform has verified the cert exists. On MyBuilder/Rated People, you must ask for the PDF.
Can I hire a tradesperson directly through HireAnything for a one-day job?
Yes. We specialise in equipment & service hire packages. For pure labour (e.g. a plasterer for a day), our marketplace lists vetted labour-only sub-contractors with verified CSCS cards and £5M PLI. Minimum booking is typically 4 hours. You get a fixed quote, method statement, and insurance certs in the app before you confirm.