You need a boiler fixed. Yesterday. You open Google, type "plumber near me" and the same three logos stare back. Checkatrade. MyBuilder. Rated People. They promise verified reviews, insurance-backed guarantees, and peace of mind. But the devil lives in the detail — specifically the fees you don't see, the review systems you can't audit, and the deposit rules that leave you exposed.
At HireAnything we've audited hundreds of bookings across all three. We've spoken to trades who pay to play, and homeowners left chasing refunds. This guide lays out the 2026 reality: what each platform costs you, how their verification actually works, and where your legal protection starts and stops.
Why the "Big Three" Still Dominate UK Trades Search in 2026
Habit. Trust signals. Marketing budgets the size of small councils. Checkatrade alone spends millions on TV slots featuring that yellow van. MyBuilder owns the "post a job, get quotes" model. Rated People leans hard on its "rated by you" strapline. Together they hoover up 70% of online tradesperson searches.
But dominance doesn't equal value. Each platform is a lead-gen engine first, a consumer champion second. The tradesperson pays — sometimes £30 per lead, sometimes a monthly subscription — and that cost quietly inflates your final invoice. You won't see it itemised. You'll just wonder why the quote feels 15% higher than a mate's recommendation.
The Hidden Cost Model
- Checkatrade: Traders pay £300–£600/year membership + £15–£30 per lead. They need 3–4 jobs just to break even on fees.
- MyBuilder: Free to join. Traders buy credits — roughly £12–£25 per quote sent. No job? Money gone.
- Rated People: Subscription tiers £25–£120/month + lead fees. High-volume traders prefer it; one-man bands often quit.
Result? You're subsidising their customer acquisition. Nothing illegal. Just opaque.
How Each Platform Actually Works (And What It Costs You)
Let's strip back the UI. You post a job. What happens next?
Checkatrade: Directory First, Matching Second
You browse profiles. You call. You arrange a quote. No platform-mediated messaging. No built-in booking. The "guarantee"? Up to £1,000 if a vetted trader goes bust mid-job — but only if you booked through their portal (rare) and the trader holds current membership. Most don't use the portal. They just want the badge on their van.
MyBuilder: Quote Marketplace
You post. Up to three traders reply. You compare. You pick. MyBuilder takes no cut of the job value. But traders factor credit costs into pricing. The platform offers a "Secure Payment" option — they hold deposit until you confirm satisfaction. Good. But uptake is low; many traders insist on bank transfer "to avoid fees".
Rated People: Lead Heavy, Control Light
Similar to MyBuilder but tighter on trader vetting. They claim 12-point checks. Reality? Mostly Companies House and insurance certificate uploads. No site visits. No skill assessments. Their "Quality Promise" refunds your platform fee (not the job cost) if work is substandard. You still need Section 75 or court for the rest.
Verified Reviews: Spotting the Fakes Before You Book
Every platform screams "verified". Dig deeper.
Checkatrade's Review Engine
Reviews only from jobs booked via their portal. That's maybe 5% of a trader's work. The rest? Invisible. A trader with 50 five-star portal reviews could have 200 angry cash customers. You'd never know.
MyBuilder's Feedback Loop
Both parties review after job completion. Traders can dispute negative reviews — and often win if paperwork is thin. Homeowners rarely pursue. Result: scores cluster at 4.7–4.9. Useless for differentiation.
Rated People's Algorithm
They weight recent reviews heavier. Good. But they also suppress reviews flagged as "disputed" — even if the dispute is unresolved. A trader in active litigation with a client still shows 4.8 stars.
Pro tip: Search the trader's name + "County Court Judgment" or "Trustpilot" before you commit. Platform reviews are marketing collateral. Court records aren't.
Deposit Protection & Cancellation: Your Legal Safety Net
This is where it gets real. You've paid £500 deposit. Trader ghosts. What now?
Platform Schemes vs Consumer Rights Act 2015
MyBuilder's Secure Payment holds funds. Checkatrade's guarantee covers trader insolvency only. Rated People refunds platform fees. None cover poor workmanship directly. Your actual protection? The Consumer Rights Act 2015: services must be carried out with reasonable care and skill. If not, you're entitled to repeat performance or price reduction. Up to 6 years in England/Wales. 5 in Scotland.
Booking Deposit Best Practice
- Never pay more than 10% upfront for materials — and only with receipted invoices.
- Use credit card (Section 75 protection on £100–£30,000) or MyBuilder Secure Payment.
- Get a written schedule: stages, payments, completion date. Email counts.
- Confirm trader's £5M Public Liability Insurance before they step on site. Ask for PDF. Check expiry.
HSE guidelines don't mandate insurance for domestic work — but any pro worth hiring carries it. No cert? Walk away.
HireAnything Difference: Direct Access, Zero Lead Fees
We built HireAnything because the platform model is broken for both sides. Traders hate paying for leads that go cold. You hate inflated quotes funding those leads.
Our marketplace connects you directly with verified Tradesperson Hire providers. No subscription. No per-lead fees. Traders list once; you book direct. Quotes are transparent — typically £75–£250/day depending on trade, region, and urgency. Booking 3–6 weeks ahead locks in peak-season availability and guarantees PIPA/HSE safety compliance on every job.
You get: written quotes, verified insurance docs, deposit protection via our escrow partner, and a cancellation policy that respects the Consumer Rights Act — not a platform's terms of service.
Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | Checkatrade | MyBuilder | Rated People | HireAnything |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cost to you (hidden) | High (trader fees passed on) | Medium | Medium-High | Zero platform markup |
| Review authenticity | Portal jobs only | Mutual, disputable | Algorithm filtered | Verified bookings only |
| Deposit protection | Insolvency only | Optional escrow | Platform fee refund | Full escrow standard |
| Cancellation rights | Platform T&Cs | Platform T&Cs | Platform T&Cs | Consumer Rights Act 2015 |
| Insurance verification | Badge only | Upload at signup | 12-point check | Live cert check per job |
Checklist: Questions to Ask Before Paying a Deposit
- Can I see your current Public Liability certificate (£5M minimum)?
- Will you provide a written quote breaking down labour, materials, VAT?
- What's the payment schedule? Stage payments tied to milestones?
- Do you offer a warranty? Written? Backed by manufacturer or insurer?
- What happens if you're ill / material delays / weather stops work?
- Can I pay deposit by credit card or escrow? (If "cash only" — red flag.)
Frequently Asked Questions
Which platform has the most genuine reviews in 2026?
None are perfect. Checkatrade's are narrowest (portal jobs only). MyBuilder's are broadest but most gamed. Rated People's algorithm hides disputes. Cross-reference with Trustpilot, Google Reviews, and Companies House filing history for the trading entity.
Am I legally protected if a trader damages my property?
Yes — if they have valid Public Liability insurance (£5M standard). Claim against their policy. If uninsured, you pursue them personally via small claims (up to £10,000). Platform guarantees rarely cover property damage; they cover platform fees or trader insolvency only.
Can I avoid platform fees by contacting traders directly?
Often yes. Many traders list contact details in profile bios or use branded vans. But you lose any platform mediation, Secure Payment, or guarantee. Weigh the saving against the risk. HireAnything removes this dilemma: direct contact, zero fees, built-in protection.
How far ahead should I book for major work (extension, rewire)?
6–8 weeks minimum for reputable firms. 12 weeks for summer starts. Good traders are booked solid. Anyone available "next week" for a £30k job is a warning sign — unless it's a cancellation slot (ask why).